|
Summary of Energy and Money by
Howard and Elizabeth Odum
To understand the economic system as a whole, it is
important to understand the relationship between money, which flows in circles
within the system, and energy, which flows through it. The effects of energy
flows and the circulation of money on both economic growth and on inflation
will be considered.
The Money Cycle
In economic process, flows of money and of energy are
closely intertwined. For example, in the production process on a farm,
high-grade potential energy flows in and low-grade dispersed heat flows out.
Money flows in from the townspeople to pay for farm produce and then flows back
to the town when farmers buy machinery and fertilizer. Some of the energy that
flows into the system is used to support the work involving these transactions
with money. The money paid to the farmer by the townspeople pays only for the
work of the farmer but not for that of the rain, soil, wind, etc. To capture
the contribution of nature, energy rather than money must be the measure of
value.
The circulation of money is dependent on the inflow of
energy; money will not circulate unless materials and energy are flowing as
well. In turn, money facilitates the flow of material and the receipt and
processing of energy, and money must therefore be seen as affecting energy
flows as well.
In the United States in 1973 there were approximately 25,000
calories' used for every dollar in circulation. This means that if a person
earned and spent $10,000 in 1973, some 250,000,000 calories were used to
support that person. Since only 1,000,000 of these calories were needed to
support the individual as represented by the food energy requirements, the
difference represents work done by farm machines, power plants, industry, and
nature.
Increases or decreases in the level of money supply are
thought to influence the level of production in the economy. However, this is
true only if the "externals" to the economy -- i.e., sources of energy from
outside of the money circle --are constant. When the availability of energy
changes, the economy changes in ways not correctable by manipulations of the
money supply.
Inflation
The buying power of money is the amount of real goods and
services that it can buy. If the amount a dollar can buy diminishes, this is
called inflation. Inflation can be caused by increasing the amount of money
circulating without increasing the amount of energy flowing and doing work, for
example, when more money is printed. It can also occur when the money supply is
constant but less work is done, for example, because energy becomes scarce. As
long as there is unused fuel energy to be tapped, increasing the money supply
can increase the flow of energy through the system, causing growth as well as
some inflation.
During wartime, even when the money supply is not increased
inflation occurs, because energy is diverted away from normal production into
military activities. This reduces the energy available per dollar in the main
economy, causing inflation.
Depression and Recession
The depression of 1929 was caused by a shortage of
circulating money, a shortage of institutions to process money, and a lack of
spending. At that time, the government undertook massive efforts to increase
the circulation of money and the flow of energy. Energy was abundant, so
stimulating the flow of money increased the inflow of energy. The recession of
the 1970s, however, was caused by a shortage of energy. Increasing the money
supply did not help in this case, as there was no increase in the inflow of
energy. Thus, if the economy is in a period of low growth, increasing the money
supply will increase the amount of work in the economy only if there are
untapped fuel reserves available. If not, increasing the money supply will only
increase inflation.
Note
Published in Howard and Elizabeth Odum, Energy Basis for Man
and Nature, New York: McGraw-Hill, 1976, 49-59. Summarized with permission of
McGraw-Hill, Inc.
1. To compare energies of different kinds, it is necessary
to express them each in units of one kind of energy required. In this paragraph
the numbers are in kilocalories of coal energy required. A new word, "eMergy,"
spelled with an "M," was coined for energies of several kinds expressed as one
kind. Thus these numbers are in units of coal eMergy.
from pp. 204-206, A SURVEY OF ECOLOGICAL ECONOMICS,
Krishnan, Harris, and Goodwin, eds., Island Press, 1995 |